Plastic Bag Rules: Allen vs Plano
How do plastic bag rules rules compare between Allen, TX and Plano, TX?
Allen and Plano have similar restriction levels.
Allen, TX
Collin County
The Texas Supreme Court in City of Laredo v. Laredo Merchants Association (2018) held that Health and Safety Code Section 361.0961 preempts municipal plastic bag bans. Cities and counties cannot prohibit or restrict retail use of plastic checkout bags as containers or packages.
View full Allen rules →Plano, TX
Collin County
Plano cannot ban single-use plastic carryout bags. The 2018 Texas Supreme Court decision in City of Laredo v. Laredo Merchants Association struck down local bag bans under the Texas Health and Safety Code Section 361.0961 preemption clause.
View full Plano rules →Key Facts Comparison
| Fact | Allen | Plano |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | HSC 361.0961 | - |
| Key Case | Laredo v. Laredo Merchants 2018 | - |
| Preemption | Mandatory bag bans void | Texas HSC 361.0961 |
| Voluntary Programs | Permitted | - |
| Key case | - | Laredo Merchants 2018 |
| Local ban | - | Not permitted |
| Voluntary fees | - | Retailer choice |
Highlighted rows indicate differences between cities.
Allen FAQ
Can any Texas city still enforce a plastic bag ban?
No. The 2018 Texas Supreme Court ruling invalidated all municipal plastic bag bans statewide, and HB 2127 (2023) further reinforces preemption against local solid waste packaging restrictions.
Can a city charge a fee for plastic bags instead?
No. The court interpreted Section 361.0961 broadly to cover both outright bans and fee-based restrictions adopted for solid waste management purposes.
Can retailers voluntarily stop offering plastic bags?
Yes. Private retailers retain the right to choose what packaging to provide. The preemption only restricts government-mandated bans, not voluntary business decisions.
Plano FAQ
Why was the Laredo bag ban struck down?
The Texas Supreme Court ruled that the local solid waste preemption statute covers single-use bags, so cities cannot ban or fee them as a waste-management measure even with home-rule authority.
Can a Plano store voluntarily charge for bags?
Yes. Private retailers can charge for bags, refuse plastic, or offer paper and reusable options as a business policy. The state preemption only blocks city-imposed bans.
Compare other topics
See how Allen and Plano compare on other ordinance categories.
Want to add a third city?
Use our full comparison tool to compare up to three cities.
Open Comparison Tool