Protected Tree Species: El Monte vs South Gate
How do protected tree species rules compare between El Monte, CA and South Gate, CA?
South Gate has fewer restrictions than El Monte.
El Monte, CA
Los Angeles County
El Monte protects 14 named California native tree species — including all native oaks, California sycamore, California walnut, California bay, and California redwood — once their trunk diameter exceeds 8 inches at breast height.
View full El Monte rules →South Gate, CA
Los Angeles County
South Gate's Municipal Code (Chapter 5.33) does NOT enumerate a list of protected species by botanical name. Instead it protects all public trees defined by size potential (mature height ≥15 ft) and location (≥1/2 of trunk on public land). California state law independently protects certain species: native oaks (Quercus spp.) on county/unincorporated land via PRC §21083.4 CEQA review, and any tree designated as habitat for state/federally listed species (e.g., raptors, monarch overwintering eucalyptus) under Fish & Game Code §3503/§3513 (bird nests).
View full South Gate rules →Key Facts Comparison
| Fact | El Monte | South Gate |
|---|---|---|
| Threshold | 8-inch diameter at 4.5 ft above grade (~25-inch circumference) | - |
| Number of protected species | 14 California natives | - |
| Includes | Coast live oak, Engelmann oak, Valley oak, California sycamore, California walnut, California redwood | - |
| Exempt | Fruit/nut trees, palms, nursery stock, certified hazardous trees | - |
| Code section | EMMC §14.03.020 (Native Tree definition) | - |
| Local Species List | - | None codified — all public trees protected uniformly |
| State Oak Protection | - | PRC §21083.4 (CEQA — county/unincorporated only) |
| Bird Nest Protection | - | Fish & Game Code §3503 / Federal MBTA |
| Nesting Season | - | Approximately Feb 1 – Aug 31 (CDFW guidance) |
| Common South Gate Street Trees | - | Mexican Fan Palm, Carrotwood, Liquidambar, Crape Myrtle (per Master Plan inventory) |
Highlighted rows indicate differences between cities.
El Monte FAQ
Which California native species are protected in El Monte?
All 14 species named in EMMC §14.03.020: Coast live oak, Engelmann oak, Canyon oak, California sycamore, California walnut, Scrub oak, Valley oak, California bay, Cottonwood (Fremont and Black), California alder, Arroyo willow, California buckeye, and California redwood — once the trunk exceeds 8 inches diameter at 4.5 ft above grade.
Is my palm tree protected in El Monte?
No. All species of palms are expressly exempt under EMMC §14.03.050(7), as are all fruit- and nut-bearing trees.
What about a California pepper tree or a non-native eucalyptus?
They are not on the Native Tree list, but they may qualify as Heritage Trees if they meet the size or height thresholds in §14.03.020 (36-inch single-trunk circumference, 75-inch multi-trunk, or 35 feet tall).
South Gate FAQ
Are oak trees specially protected in South Gate?
California's main oak-protection statute (PRC §21083.4) applies to discretionary projects in unincorporated counties, not incorporated cities like South Gate. Locally, oaks on public land are protected the same as any other public tree under SGMC 5.33; oaks on private land in South Gate have no special local protection unless a planning condition of approval applies.
Can I cut down a tree in the spring?
Be very careful. California Fish & Game Code §3503 and the federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act make it unlawful to destroy any active bird nest — even on private property. Industry-standard practice is to avoid tree work between February 1 and August 31, or to retain a qualified biologist to perform a nest survey within 3 days of the work.
What about palm trees — are those protected?
Yes when on public land. Mexican Fan Palm and Date Palm specimens lining South Gate's streets are 'public trees' under SGMC 5.33 (they exceed the 15-ft mature height threshold) and require a Public Works permit to remove or prune.
Compare other topics
See how El Monte and South Gate compare on other ordinance categories.
Want to add a third city?
Use our full comparison tool to compare up to three cities.
Open Comparison Tool