Garfield vs Mahwah
How do tree replacement requirements rules compare between Garfield, NJ and Mahwah, NJ?
Garfield and Mahwah have similar restriction levels.
Garfield, NJ
Bergen County
Garfield requires replacement plantings after qualifying tree removals, using a city-approved species list and excluding invasive species.
View full Garfield rules →Mahwah, NJ
Bergen County
Mahwah requires replacement trees of equal or greater DBH for every protected tree removed, planted within 12 months, or compensatory payment into the Mahwah Tree Bank escrow account.
View full Mahwah rules →Key Facts Comparison
| Fact | Garfield | Mahwah |
|---|---|---|
| Non-homeowner trigger | 1+ tree, 6 inch DBH | - |
| Homeowner trigger | More than 3 trees per acre | - |
| Lookback period | Five years | - |
| Banned species | NJ Strike Team Do Not Plant List | - |
| Replacement DBH | - | Equal or greater than removed |
| Planting deadline | - | Within 12 months |
| Approved species | - | Native northern NJ hardwoods |
| Fee-in-lieu fund | - | Mahwah Tree Bank escrow |
Highlighted rows indicate differences between cities.
Garfield FAQ
Can I pay a fee instead of replanting?
Garfield's ordinance allows planting additional trees in lieu of paying the standard $250 fine for unlawful removal, but routine replacements after permitted removal must be planted on site.
Where do I find Garfield's approved replacement species list?
The Building Department distributes the approved species list at the time the tree removal permit is issued, along with Right Tree Right Place placement guidelines.
Mahwah FAQ
Can I pay a fee instead of planting replacement trees in Mahwah?
Yes. Funds collected in lieu of replanting are deposited into the Mahwah Tree Bank, an escrow account used for township-wide tree planting projects.
How quickly must replacement trees be planted after removal?
Replacement trees must be planted within 12 months of the original tree's removal date, using species approved under Chapter 14 standards.
Do replacements need to match the size of the removed tree?
Replacements must have equal or greater DBH than the removed tree, or meet the alternative Tree Replacement Criteria detailed in Chapter 14.
Compare other topics
See how Garfield and Mahwah compare on other ordinance categories.
Want to add a third city?
Use our full comparison tool to compare up to three cities.
Open Comparison Tool