Tree Replacement Requirements: Goodyear vs Scottsdale
How do tree replacement requirements rules compare between Goodyear, AZ and Scottsdale, AZ?
Goodyear has fewer restrictions than Scottsdale.
Goodyear, AZ
Maricopa County
Goodyear does not mandate tree replacement for private property tree removal. The Zoning Ordinance requires landscape plans for new development that include minimum tree plantings. The Urban Forestry Department manages replacement of public trees removed for maintenance or development. HOAs in master-planned communities often require replacement of trees removed from front yards.
View full Goodyear rules →Scottsdale, AZ
Maricopa County
Scottsdale's Native Plant Ordinance (Chapter 46, Article V) requires replacement or relocation of protected native plants that cannot be preserved in place during development. Replacement must be with plants from the Indigenous Plant List. The Zoning Ordinance Article X sets landscaping requirements including tree planting standards for new development.
View full Scottsdale rules →Key Facts Comparison
| Fact | Goodyear | Scottsdale |
|---|---|---|
| Private Requirement | No general replacement mandate | - |
| New Development | Landscape plans with tree minimums | Article X requires trees in landscape areas |
| Public Trees | 1:1 replacement by Urban Forestry | - |
| HOA Rules | Often require front-yard replacement | - |
| Contact | (623) 932-3200 Urban Forestry | - |
| Primary Goal | - | Preserve in place; relocate as second option; replace as last resort |
| Replacement Plants | - | Must be from Scottsdale Indigenous Plant List |
| Violation Fine | - | Up to $10,000 per protected plant |
| Minimum Caliper | - | Typically 2 inches at installation |
| ESLO Review | - | More stringent; preservation strongly preferred |
Highlighted rows indicate differences between cities.
Goodyear FAQ
Do I have to replace a tree I remove in Goodyear?
The city does not have a general tree replacement requirement for private property. However, your HOA likely requires replacement of front-yard trees with approved species. Check your CC&Rs before removing any trees.
What trees should I plant in Goodyear?
Desert-adapted species are recommended including palo verde, mesquite, ironwood, desert willow, and native shade trees. The Urban Forestry Department can provide guidance on appropriate species for the Goodyear climate.
Does new development in Goodyear require tree planting?
Yes. The Zoning Ordinance requires landscape plans for new development that include minimum tree plantings with desert-appropriate species. These requirements are reviewed during the development approval process.
Scottsdale FAQ
If I must remove a protected tree, do I have to replace it?
Yes. Scottsdale requires salvage and relocation first. If not feasible, replacement with plants from the Indigenous Plant List is required. The replacement details are set through the Native Plant Program review.
What size replacement trees does Scottsdale require?
Replacement trees for new development landscaping must typically be at least 2-inch caliper at installation. Protected native plant replacement specifications are set through individual project review.
What happens if I don't replace removed native plants?
Fines up to $10,000 per plant may be assessed, and final inspections or certificates of occupancy may be withheld until replacement planting is completed.
Compare other topics
See how Goodyear and Scottsdale compare on other ordinance categories.
Want to add a third city?
Use our full comparison tool to compare up to three cities.
Open Comparison Tool