Tree Replacement Requirements: New Rochelle vs Yonkers
How do tree replacement requirements rules compare between New Rochelle, NY and Yonkers, NY?
Yonkers has fewer restrictions than New Rochelle.
New Rochelle, NY
Westchester County
Tree removal permits typically require replacement planting. Replacement is on a caliper-inch basis (inches removed equals inches replanted) or via payment into a city tree fund.
View full New Rochelle rules →Yonkers, NY
Westchester County
Yonkers tree preservation ordinance requires replacement plantings when protected trees are removed, especially as part of development projects. Replacement ratios vary by tree size.
View full Yonkers rules →Key Facts Comparison
| Fact | New Rochelle | Yonkers |
|---|---|---|
| Standard | Caliper-inch replacement | - |
| Typical Size | 2.5-3 inch caliper | - |
| Fee-in-Lieu | City tree fund | - |
| Species | Native preferred | Native hardwoods preferred |
| Requirement | - | Replacement for removals |
| Ratio | - | Varies by size |
| Fee-in-lieu | - | Allowed if infeasible |
Highlighted rows indicate differences between cities.
New Rochelle FAQ
Do I have to replant every tree I remove?
Generally yes, for permitted removals. Replacement is typically calculated on total caliper inches. Fee-in-lieu options exist where on-site replanting isn't feasible.
What size replacement tree does New Rochelle require?
Typical replacements use 2.5 to 3 inch caliper nursery stock. Total caliper inches replanted should equal the caliper inches removed under Chapter 292.
Can I pay a fee instead of planting a replacement tree in New Rochelle?
Yes. If on-site replanting is impractical, you may pay into the city's tree fund, which supports street tree and park tree planting elsewhere in New Rochelle.
Yonkers FAQ
Do I have to plant a new tree if I remove an old one?
For development-related removals, yes — replacement is required. For routine homeowner removal of smaller trees, replacement may not be mandated.
What tree replacement ratio does Yonkers require?
Replacement ratios typically start at 1:1 and go higher depending on the caliper of the removed tree. The Yonkers tree preservation ordinance bases the ratio on trunk size during site plan review.
Can I pay a fee instead of replanting a tree in Yonkers?
Yes. Where on-site replacement is not feasible, fees-in-lieu may be paid to a city tree fund for planting elsewhere. Species lists favor native Hudson Valley hardwoods.
Compare other topics
See how New Rochelle and Yonkers compare on other ordinance categories.
Want to add a third city?
Use our full comparison tool to compare up to three cities.
Open Comparison Tool