ADU Impact Fees: Albany vs Colonie
How do adu impact fees rules compare between Albany, NY and Colonie, NY?
Albany and Colonie have similar restriction levels.
Albany, NY
Albany County
New York is not a development impact fee state in the California or Washington sense; the Legislature has not enacted a general municipal impact fee enabling statute. Localities derive site-specific exaction authority from State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA) findings and subdivision/site plan review, but flat per-unit residential impact fees are rare and legally constrained. Albany charges building permit fees, plan review fees, and utility connection charges, but no separate parks, transportation, or school impact fees on ADU construction.
View full Albany rules →Colonie, NY
Albany County
New York has not enacted a general municipal impact-fee enabling statute, and New York courts have historically scrutinized exactions outside specific statutory authority. Colonie does not impose general development impact fees on residential construction; ADU applicants typically face only standard zoning permit fees, building permit fees under 19 NYCRR Part 1203, and water and sewer connection fees through Town water districts or the Albany County Sewer District. School districts in New York lack impact-fee authority and are funded through the state aid formula under NY Education Law §3602. Recreation fees-in-lieu may apply to subdivisions under NY Town Law §277(4) but generally not to single-lot infill ADUs.
View full Colonie rules →Key Facts Comparison
| Fact | Albany | Colonie |
|---|---|---|
| Impact Fee Authority | None statewide in New York | - |
| Key Precedent | Albany Area Builders v. Guilderland (1989) | - |
| Accessory Structure Permit | ~$50-$100 (Albany Fee Chart) | - |
| Building Code | 19 NYCRR 1219 | - |
| School Impact Fees | Not authorized in NY | - |
| SEQRA Status | Type II (single-parcel ADU normally exempt) | - |
| NY Impact Fee Authority | - | No general statute |
| Controlling Case | - | Albany Area Builders v. Guilderland (1989) |
| Colonie Impact Fees | - | Not imposed on ADUs |
| Permit Fees | - | Zoning + Building (set by Town) |
| Water Connection | - | Latham Water District / Town districts |
| Sewer Connection | - | Albany County Sewer District |
Highlighted rows indicate differences between cities.
Albany FAQ
Does Albany charge impact fees on a new ADU?
No traditional impact fees. New York has no general impact fee enabling statute, and the leading case (Albany Area Builders v. Town of Guilderland, 74 N.Y.2d 372 (1989)) restricts municipal authority to impose them. Costs are limited to USDO review fees, building/electrical/plumbing/mechanical permit fees under the Albany Fee Chart, plan review charges, and Albany Water Department tap fees if a new service is installed.
Are there school or parks fees on an ADU?
No. New York does not authorize school, parks, or transportation impact fees on residential development. Albany City School District is funded through the state foundation aid formula plus the city's school tax levy on assessed value. New construction contributes to schools and city services through ongoing property tax assessments on the increased value rather than upfront impact fees.
Colonie FAQ
Does Colonie charge an impact fee for ADUs?
Colonie does not impose general development impact fees on residential construction including ADUs. The New York Court of Appeals in Albany Area Builders Ass'n v. Town of Guilderland, 74 N.Y.2d 372 (1989) struck down a neighboring town's transportation impact fee for lack of statutory authority, and the holding remains controlling. New York towns generally rely on permit fees, water and sewer connection fees, and subdivision parkland dedication or fees-in-lieu under Town Law §277 rather than impact fees. ADU applicants typically pay only zoning and building permit fees plus water/sewer connection fees.
Can New York school districts charge impact fees on new homes?
No. New York school districts under the Education Law lack impact-fee authority and are funded through the state aid formula under NY Education Law §3602. The state has not enacted a school impact-fee enabling statute. Towns like Colonie likewise lack a general impact-fee statute under Albany Area Builders v. Guilderland and cannot impose unauthorized exactions on residential development including ADUs.
Compare other topics
See how Albany and Colonie compare on other ordinance categories.
Want to add a third city?
Use our full comparison tool to compare up to three cities.
Open Comparison Tool