Skip to main content
CityRuleLookup
🏠 Short-Term Rentals/Permit Requirements

Permit Requirements: Buffalo vs Clarence

How do permit requirements rules compare between Buffalo, NY and Clarence, NY?

Buffalo and Clarence have similar restriction levels.

Buffalo, NY

Erie County

Heavy Restrictions

Buffalo requires all short-term rental operators to obtain a Short-Term Rental license from the City Clerk under Buffalo Code Chapter 242. Hosts must register, pass safety inspection, and operate only in approved zoning districts. Hosted and non-hosted rentals have different rules.

View full Buffalo rules β†’

Clarence, NY

Erie County

Heavy Restrictions

Erie County does not issue its own STR land-use permit, but every short-term rental operator must register with the Erie County Comptroller and collect a county hotel occupancy tax under Local Law 12-1974, as amended effective January 4, 2024 to expressly cover short-term and vacation rentals booked for under 30 consecutive days.

View full Clarence rules β†’

Key Facts Comparison

FactBuffaloClarence
CodeChapter 242 City Code-
LicenseAnnual via City Clerk-
InspectionSafety inspection required-
Local ContactWithin 25 miles-
Fines500-1000 dollars per violation-
--

Highlighted rows indicate differences between cities.

Buffalo FAQ

Can I list on Airbnb without a Buffalo license?

No. Buffalo Code Chapter 242 requires all STR operators to hold a current city license before listing or renting.

How long does the Buffalo STR license process take?

Typically 30-60 days depending on inspection scheduling and application completeness.

Clarence FAQ

Do I need a permit from Erie County to run an Airbnb?

Erie County itself does not issue an STR land-use permit, but you must register with the Erie County Comptroller under Local Law 12-1974 and collect the county hotel occupancy tax. Your city, town, or village (for example, the City of Buffalo) may also require a separate local STR permit.

What is the Erie County STR tax rate?

The county hotel occupancy tax is 3% for lodging with 30 or fewer rooms and 5% for lodging with more than 30 rooms. Almost all short-term rentals (single homes, apartments, condos) fall in the 3% tier. This is collected on top of New York State and local sales tax.

When are Erie County STR tax returns due?

Returns are filed quarterly with the Erie County Comptroller, due March 20, June 20, September 20, and December 20. Operators who remit less than $250 per year may elect to file once a year instead. Late returns incur a 5% penalty plus 1% monthly interest.

What counts as a short-term rental in Erie County?

Any rental of a room, dwelling, or other lodging for fewer than 30 consecutive days is treated as a taxable short-term rental under the amended Local Law 12-1974, including Airbnb, VRBO, and other platform listings as well as private direct bookings.

Want to add a third city?

Use our full comparison tool to compare up to three cities.

Open Comparison Tool