Skip to main content
CityRuleLookup
🏠 Short-Term Rentals/Taxes & Fees

Taxes & Fees: Buffalo vs Clarence

How do taxes & fees rules compare between Buffalo, NY and Clarence, NY?

Buffalo has fewer restrictions than Clarence.

Buffalo, NY

Erie County

Some Restrictions

Buffalo STR operators must collect Erie County 5 percent hotel occupancy tax plus NY State sales tax (8.75 percent in Erie County). Airbnb and Vrbo collect and remit state sales tax but Erie County bed tax is the host responsibility unless platform has a separate agreement.

View full Buffalo rules β†’

Clarence, NY

Erie County

Heavy Restrictions

Every Erie County short-term rental operator must register with the Erie County Comptroller and collect a county hotel occupancy tax. Local Law No. 12-1974, as amended effective January 4, 2024, expressly covers "a short term rental or vacation rental" booked for fewer than 30 consecutive days. The rate is 3% for lodging with 30 or fewer rooms and 5% for more than 30 rooms, separate from New York State and local sales tax.

View full Clarence rules β†’

Key Facts Comparison

FactBuffaloClarence
Erie County Bed Tax5 percent-
NY Sales Tax8.75 percent combined-
Total TaxApproximately 13.75 percent-
License Fee200-350 dollars annual-
FilingMonthly-
--

Highlighted rows indicate differences between cities.

Buffalo FAQ

Does Airbnb collect Erie County bed tax?

Airbnb collects NY State sales tax. Erie County bed tax responsibility depends on the platform agreement. Hosts should register with Erie County Comptroller.

What is the total tax on a Buffalo STR stay?

Approximately 13.75 percent: 5 percent Erie County plus 8.75 percent combined NY sales tax.

Clarence FAQ

What is the Erie County hotel occupancy tax rate for short-term rentals?

The county hotel occupancy tax is 3% for lodging with 30 or fewer rooms and 5% for lodging with more than 30 rooms. Almost all short-term rentals (single homes, apartments, condos) fall in the 3% tier under Local Law 12-1974, as amended effective January 4, 2024.

When are Erie County STR tax returns due?

Returns are filed quarterly with the Erie County Comptroller, due March 20, June 20, September 20, and December 20. Operators remitting less than $250 per year may elect to file once a year. Late returns incur a 5% penalty plus 1% monthly interest after the first month.

Do I owe NY State sales tax on top of the Erie County hotel tax?

Yes. Effective March 1, 2025, New York State and local sales tax also apply to short-term rental unit occupancy when the rental rate is more than $2.00 per unit per day. This is collected separately from the Erie County 3%/5% hotel occupancy tax under Local Law 12-1974.

How do I register my Erie County short-term rental?

File a Certificate of Registration with the Erie County Comptroller's Hotel Tax Division at 95 Franklin Street, Room 1100, Buffalo, NY 14202 within three days of opening or acquiring the rental. The form is available at www4.erie.gov/comptroller; questions can be directed to ErieCountyBedTax@erie.gov.

Want to add a third city?

Use our full comparison tool to compare up to three cities.

Open Comparison Tool