Fair Lawn vs Garfield
How do tree replacement requirements rules compare between Fair Lawn, NJ and Garfield, NJ?
Fair Lawn and Garfield have similar restriction levels.
Fair Lawn, NJ
Bergen County
Fair Lawn requires replacement plantings or contributions to a tree fund when permitted trees are removed, with ratios based on size.
View full Fair Lawn rules →Garfield, NJ
Bergen County
Garfield requires replacement plantings after qualifying tree removals, using a city-approved species list and excluding invasive species.
View full Garfield rules →Key Facts Comparison
| Fact | Fair Lawn | Garfield |
|---|---|---|
| Replacement basis | Size-based ratio | - |
| Approved species | Commission list | - |
| Minimum caliper | Set by ordinance | - |
| Fund option | If site-impractical | - |
| Approval | Shade Tree Commission | - |
| Non-homeowner trigger | - | 1+ tree, 6 inch DBH |
| Homeowner trigger | - | More than 3 trees per acre |
| Lookback period | - | Five years |
| Banned species | - | NJ Strike Team Do Not Plant List |
Highlighted rows indicate differences between cities.
Fair Lawn FAQ
How many trees must I plant to replace one removed?
It depends on the size of the removed tree. Larger trees require more or larger replacement plantings under the ordinance ratio.
Can I pay a fee instead of planting a replacement?
In some cases, yes. The borough may accept payment into the tree fund when on-site replanting is impractical, subject to commission approval.
Garfield FAQ
Can I pay a fee instead of replanting?
Garfield's ordinance allows planting additional trees in lieu of paying the standard $250 fine for unlawful removal, but routine replacements after permitted removal must be planted on site.
Where do I find Garfield's approved replacement species list?
The Building Department distributes the approved species list at the time the tree removal permit is issued, along with Right Tree Right Place placement guidelines.
Compare other topics
See how Fair Lawn and Garfield compare on other ordinance categories.
Want to add a third city?
Use our full comparison tool to compare up to three cities.
Open Comparison Tool