Tree Replacement Requirements: Homestead vs Miami Beach
How do tree replacement requirements rules compare between Homestead, FL and Miami Beach, FL?
Homestead has fewer restrictions than Miami Beach.
Homestead, FL
Miami-Dade County
Miami-Dade County requires tree replacement when removal permits are granted under Section 24-49. Replacement ratios are determined by DERM based on the species, size, and significance of the removed tree.
View full Homestead rules βMiami Beach, FL
Miami-Dade County
When tree removal is approved in Miami Beach, the city requires replacement trees of equivalent or greater value. Chapter 126 mandates replacement ratios based on the removed tree's size, species, and condition. The Miami-Dade County Landscape Manual provides valuation standards. Payment into a tree trust fund may be accepted when on-site planting is infeasible.
View full Miami Beach rules βKey Facts Comparison
| Fact | Homestead | Miami Beach |
|---|---|---|
| Requirement | Condition of removal permit | - |
| Ratios | Set by DERM | - |
| Native Species | Preferred | - |
| Alternative | Tree replacement fund | Tree trust fund payment |
| Maintenance | Required period | - |
| Replacement Required | - | Equivalent or greater value |
| Minimum Size | - | 12-14 feet height, 3-inch caliper |
| Species Preference | - | Native and Florida-friendly |
| Prohibited | - | Invasive exotic species |
Highlighted rows indicate differences between cities.
Homestead FAQ
Do I have to replace trees I remove?
Usually yes. DERM determines replacement requirements as a condition of the removal permit based on species, size, and significance of the removed tree.
What species should replacement trees be?
Native South Florida species are generally preferred. DERM specifies acceptable replacement species and minimum size requirements as part of the permit conditions.
Miami Beach FAQ
How many replacement trees are required when removing a tree in Miami Beach?
Replacement ratios are determined by the city arborist based on the removed tree's size, species, and condition. The goal is equivalent or greater canopy value replacement.
What if I don't have room for replacement trees?
When on-site planting is infeasible due to space constraints, the city may accept payment into a tree trust fund used for public tree planting throughout Miami Beach.
What species can be used as replacement trees?
Native and Florida-friendly species are preferred. Invasive exotic species are prohibited. The Miami-Dade County Landscape Manual provides approved species lists. Contact Urban Forestry for guidance.
Compare other topics
See how Homestead and Miami Beach compare on other ordinance categories.
Want to add a third city?
Use our full comparison tool to compare up to three cities.
Open Comparison Tool