Sanctuary Policy Preemption: Miami vs Miami Gardens
How do sanctuary policy preemption rules compare between Miami, FL and Miami Gardens, FL?
Miami and Miami Gardens have similar restriction levels.
Miami, FL
Miami-Dade County
Florida SB 168 (2019) prohibits sanctuary policies and requires state and local agencies to honor federal immigration detainers and cooperate with ICE. Miami complies; the city does not have, and cannot adopt, a sanctuary policy.
View full Miami rules →Miami Gardens, FL
Miami-Dade County
Miami-Dade is not a sanctuary jurisdiction. After being labeled a sanctuary 2013 to 2017, then-Mayor Carlos Gimenez ordered full ICE cooperation in January 2017. Florida Senate Bill 168 (2019) requires all Florida sheriffs to honor ICE detainer requests.
View full Miami Gardens rules →Key Facts Comparison
| Fact | Miami | Miami Gardens |
|---|---|---|
| Florida statute | FL Sec. 908.101-908.111 | - |
| Enacting bill | SB 168 (2019) | - |
| ICE detainer rule | Mandatory cooperation | - |
| Civil penalty | Up to $5,000 per day | - |
| Miami status | Compliant, no sanctuary policy | - |
| State law | - | FL Chapter 908 (SB 168) |
| Sanctuary period | - | 2013-2017 |
| Ended by | - | Mayor Gimenez Jan 2017 |
| Detainer hold | - | 48 hours max |
Highlighted rows indicate differences between cities.
Miami FAQ
Is Miami a sanctuary city?
No. Florida SB 168 (2019) prohibits sanctuary policies statewide. Miami Police Department and Miami-Dade County jails cooperate with ICE, including honoring federal immigration detainers as required by Florida Statute 908.
What happens if a Miami official adopts sanctuary rules?
The Governor can remove them from office under Section 908.107. Civil penalties run up to $5,000 per day per violation, and officials may face personal liability for damages caused by an immigrant released contrary to a detainer.
Miami Gardens FAQ
Will local police ask about my immigration status?
Patrol officers do not routinely check immigration status. ICE involvement begins after a county jail booking, where status is checked through federal databases under state law.
Can Miami-Dade become a sanctuary again?
Not under current state law. Florida Chapter 908 bans sanctuary policies, requires ICE cooperation, and allows removal of local officials who refuse to comply.
Compare other topics
See how Miami and Miami Gardens compare on other ordinance categories.
Want to add a third city?
Use our full comparison tool to compare up to three cities.
Open Comparison Tool