Tree Replacement Requirements: Sutter vs Yuba City

If a landscape tree dies, can I replace it with a smaller tree?

No. Per Article 60 §8-5.6007, replacement must match the original species, size, and quality specified on the approved landscape plan, unless the Planning Director approves a substitute. Smaller substitutes may be allowed for species with poor survival in Yuba City's climate, but written approval is required.

Do I have to replace a parkway tree that died of natural causes?

If the parkway tree was part of a subdivision approval, the developer or HOA is typically responsible during the warranty period. After warranty, the public-right-of-way tree becomes a city tree managed by Parks Maintenance, and the city handles replacement. Trees on private property required as part of a development approval remain the owner's responsibility.

What species should I use for replacement?

Yuba City Parks Division publishes a Recommended Street Trees list (2009) with three categories: parkway/median trees (large deciduous like Valley Oak, Red Maple, Chinese Pistache), trees for under power lines (smaller species like Crape Myrtle, Eastern Redbud), and parking lot shade trees. Substitutes not on the list require Parks Division approval.