Manhattan condo and co-op disputes are generally handled through board hearings, mediation, NY Attorney General complaints, or litigation in state Supreme Court.
Disputes between owners and boards in Manhattan condos and co-ops can be resolved through several channels. Internal dispute procedures are typically set out in bylaws and house rules, ranging from written complaints to board hearings. The NY Attorney General Real Estate Finance Bureau accepts complaints about offering plan violations, financial disclosures, and certain governance failures under RPL Article 23-A. The business judgment rule (Matter of Levandusky) gives boards broad deference in Supreme Court, New York County Commercial Division litigation, meaning courts rarely overturn board decisions absent bad faith, discrimination, or ultra vires action. Mediation through community dispute resolution centers and arbitration (if required by bylaws) are alternative avenues. Federal and NY State Human Rights Law complaints handle discrimination. Small disputes between neighbors often go to Civil Court, Housing Part.
Contact your local code enforcement office for specific penalty information.
See how New York County's dispute resolution rules stack up against other locations.
Help us keep this page accurate. If you notice an error or outdated information, let us know.