Orange County, NY Right to Farm: Farm Nuisance Protection (2026)
Key Facts
- Governing law
- Local Law No. 6 of 2006, effective Jan. 1, 2007
- Core protection
- Sound agricultural practices deemed reasonable, not a nuisance
- Legislature vote
- Passed 19-0 by County Legislature, July 6, 2006
- Dispute forum
- Dispute Resolution Center, 14 Scotchtown Avenue, Goshen
- Carve-out
- Water pollution and overflow damage claims stay actionable
- Disclosure duty
- Sellers in ag districts must give buyers written notice
Summary
Orange County Local Law No. 6 of 2006 shields farms from nuisance lawsuits. Under Section 3, agricultural activities on farmland are deemed reasonable and cannot be ruled a nuisance if they follow sound agricultural practices approved by the New York State Commissioner of Agriculture and Markets. The law, effective January 1, 2007, protects noise, odors, dust, irrigation pumping, aerial spraying and slow-moving farm equipment on county roads from neighbor complaints.
Notwithstanding any other provision of this Local Law, agricultural activities conducted on farmland, if consistent with sound agricultural practices as may be determined by the New York State Commissioner of Agriculture and Markets and with Federal, State, and local laws, regulations or ordinances, are deemed to be reasonable and shall not constitute a nuisance.
Full Breakdown
Orange County adopted the Right-to-Farm Policy as Local Law No. 6 of 2006, declaring it county policy to conserve and encourage agricultural land use as nonagricultural development pushes into farm areas (Section 1). Section 2 defines 'agricultural activities' by cross-reference to Section 301 of Article 25-AA of the state Agriculture and Markets Law: field crops, vegetables, fruit, livestock and livestock products including cattle, sheep, horses and poultry, Christmas tree operations, aquaculture and forestry products such as maple syrup. 'Farmland' means land within an Orange County Agricultural District created under Section 303 of Article 25-AA, or land receiving an agricultural assessment under Section 306.
The 'right to farm' explicitly covers large irrigation pumps, aerial and ground seeding and spraying, transporting slow-moving equipment on county roads, and hiring farm labor, at any hour of any day including holidays, with the resulting noise, odors, dust and fumes folded into the protected activity. Section 3 is the operative shield: agricultural activities on farmland that follow sound agricultural practices, as the state Commissioner of Agriculture and Markets may determine, and that comply with other federal, state and local law, are deemed reasonable and cannot be found a nuisance.
Section 4 encourages town planning boards to require a right-to-farm notice recorded in subdivision deeds near working farms. Section 5 requires sellers of property inside an Orange County Agricultural District to give buyers written notice under Real Property Law Section 333-c before closing. Section 6 routes farm-versus-neighbor disputes to the Dispute Resolution Center at 14 Scotchtown Avenue in Goshen for mediation under the state's Agricultural Mediation Program. The law took effect January 1, 2007, after passing the County Legislature 19-0 on July 6, 2006.
Violations & Fines
This is a legal defense, not a penalty scheme: a farm sued for nuisance over noise, dust, odors or off-hour operations can point to Section 3 and have the claim dismissed if its practices are sound and lawful. The shield has limits. Section 7 preserves any neighbor's right to sue a farm for damages caused by stream pollution or altered water flow, and the defense evaporates if practices violate other federal, state or local law.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a neighbor sue an Orange County farm over noise or dust?
What land counts as 'farmland' under the law?
Where do farm-neighbor disputes get resolved?
Does the right-to-farm law block a stream-pollution lawsuit?
Sources & Official References
Other rules in Orange County
New York rules heatmap·Compare Orange County to another location·View the New York right to farm overview
See something wrong?
Help us keep this page accurate. If you notice an error or outdated information, let us know.