New York Statewide Rule
New York Charitable Gaming Requires Local Option
Key Facts
- Governing law
- Gen. Mun. Law Arts. 9-A (games of chance) & 14-H (bingo)
- Adoption method
- Local law/ordinance plus majority-of-electors referendum required
- Village games-of-chance
- Village piggybacks on town's law via permissive-referendum resolution
- Village bingo
- Village's own bingo law ousts the town's authority there
- State regulator
- New York State Gaming Commission (merged 2013)
- State ID needed
- Each org also needs a Games of Chance/Bingo ID number
- Unlicensed penalty
- Promoting gambling. Class A misdemeanor or Class E felony
Summary
New York grants no automatic right to run charitable gambling. General Municipal Law Article 9-A lets a town, city, or village opt in to games of chance by local law or ordinance, but that law only takes effect after voters approve it in a referendum; Article 14-H imposes the identical referendum requirement for bingo. Until a specific municipality adopts and voters ratify it, no authorized organization there may legally hold a game of chance or bingo night.
§ 187. Local option. Subject to the provisions of this article, and pursuant to the direction contained in subdivision two of section nine of article one of the constitution of the state, the legislature hereby gives and grants to every municipality the right, power and authority to authorize the conduct of games of chance by authorized organizations within the territorial limits of such municipality. A local law or ordinance adopted by a town shall be operative in any village or within any part of any village located within such town if, after adoption of such local law or ordinance, the board of trustees of such village adopts a local law or resolution subject to a permissive referendum as provided in article nine of the village law authorizing the issuance of licenses by the town for games of chance within such village. Such local law or resolution may be repealed only by a local law or resolution which shall also be subject to a permissive referendum, or by enactment of a local law authorizing games of chance as provided in section one hundred eighty-eight of this article.
Full Breakdown
New York's charitable-gambling framework is opt-in at the town, city, or village level, not statewide. General Municipal Law § 187 gives 'every municipality the right, power and authority to authorize the conduct of games of chance by authorized organizations within the territorial limits of such municipality', authority the legislature does not exercise on any municipality's behalf. ' A vote of the town board or city council alone is not enough; the measure must also clear a townwide or citywide referendum. Article 14-H imposes the identical mechanic for bingo, with a twist: § 477 grants the same local-option authority, but if a village's electors separately approve their own bingo local law under § 478, the surrounding town's authority no longer extends into that village for as long as the village law stays in effect.
Games of chance work the opposite way, § 187 lets a village piggyback on its town's already-adopted law by passing its own local law or permissive-referendum resolution, rather than displacing the town's reach. Once adopted, either law can be undone only by another local law or resolution that goes through the same public-vote process. Even after a municipality opts in, an authorized organization still cannot run either activity without its own Games of Chance/Bingo Identification Number from the New York State Gaming Commission, a separate application (Commission Form 1A) the agency says takes eight to ten weeks to process. Skip either the municipal referendum or the state identification number, and the activity is unlicensed no matter how charitable the organization.
Violations & Penalties
Operating games of chance or bingo without both the municipal local law and a state Identification Number falls outside the licensed-gambling exemption in Penal Law § 225.00, so it can be charged as promoting gambling: a Class A misdemeanor, or a Class E felony for larger operations. The municipality can deny, suspend, or revoke the local license, and the Gaming Commission can deny or pull an organization's Games of Chance or Bingo Identification Number for licensing violations.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does every New York town or city allow charitable games of chance and bingo?
How does a village get games of chance if its town already adopted the law?
Is a municipal license enough, or do charities need something from the state too?
What happens if a group runs a raffle-style game of chance without local approval?
Sources
See something wrong?
Help us keep this page accurate. If you notice an error or outdated information, let us know.