South Dakota Statewide Rule
South Dakota Plastic Bag Preemption Framework
Key Facts
- Statewide Plastic
- No statewide plastic bag ban
- Statewide Preemption
- No statewide preemption statute
- Sdcl 9-32
- SDCL 9-32 governs municipal solid waste authority
- Dillon's Rule
- Dillon's Rule limits city packaging regulation
- South Dakota
- No South Dakota city has enacted a bag ban
Summary
South Dakota's municipal authority under SDCL 9-32 does not authorize cities to ban plastic bags, and statewide policy favors uniform commerce rules without local plastic restrictions.
The provisions of chapter 34A-7 relating to beverage containers, garbage bags, and garbage can liners, auxiliary containers, and § 34A-6-68 relating to uniform recycling codes for plastic containers, preempt all laws by any other political subdivision of the state relating to auxiliary containers, beverage containers, garbage bags, straws used for beverage consumption, or plastic packaging materials. No other political subdivision of the state may enact any law restricting the use in commerce of auxiliary containers, beverage containers, garbage bags, straws used for beverage consumption, or plastic packaging materials. Nothing in §§ 34A-6-59 to 34A-6-92, inclusive, may be construed to limit a political subdivision from allowing or requiring specially designated garbage bags for the purpose of identifying volume or type of waste or restricting the use of glass bottles and containers within park or recreation sites and facilities due to public safety concerns.
Full Breakdown
Under SDCL Title 9 Chapter 32 and SDCL 9-29 governing municipal powers, cities may regulate solid waste collection but lack express authority to ban auxiliary containers like plastic bags. Although South Dakota has not passed an explicit auxiliary container preemption statute like neighboring states, no city has enacted a plastic bag ban, and local ordinances regulating retail packaging would face challenges under Dillon's Rule limiting municipal authority to expressly granted powers.
Violations & Penalties
If a city enacted a plastic bag ban, retailers could challenge it as ultra vires; courts would assess authority under Dillon's Rule and SDCL 9-32 solid waste provisions.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a South Dakota city ban single-use plastic bags?
Does South Dakota tax plastic bags?
Sources
See something wrong?
Help us keep this page accurate. If you notice an error or outdated information, let us know.